Universal Time: 19:57  |  Local Time: 19:57 (3h GMT)
Select your timezone:

P.499 Ethics of organ donation and transplantation – The road traversed

Vasanthi Ramesh, India

Founder Director NOTTO and HAG Officer
Surgery
Vardhman Mahavir Medical College & Safdarjung Hospital

Abstract

Ethics of organ donation and transplantation – The road traversed

Vasanthi Ramesh1,2.

1Founder Director NOTTO,, Vardhaman Mahavir Medical College and Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi, India; 2General Surgery, Vardhaman Mahavir Medical College and Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi, India

Introduction: 10% of transplants worldwide in 2007 were unethical  . The declaration of Istanbul(DoI) 2008 on organ trafficking and transplant tourism was developed for tackling ethical issues in transplantation rampant then and   Declaration of Istanbul Custodian Group (DICG)  revised the declaration by a consultative process in 2018. This study  analyzes the success of our mission and  further steps to be taken.
Materials and Methods: A literature search on transplantation ethics, legal developments and organ trafficking was done and  analyzed
Results: Nature  (News)  1988 published “US anger over accusations·of trafficking in infant organs”.  Latin American countries sell babies for adoption in the US, existence of  illegal adoption services admitted to by  US officials . A resolution   by the European Parliament (1988)  accused the United States of trafficking in organs from human infants. Yosuke Shimazono, in his review “The state of the international organ trade” quotes  price  for organs  from China, Pakistan and Phillipines websites.(Bulletin of WHO, 2007). Hundreds of documents and media reports, scores of journal articles and documents analysed showed media reports were more useful tools. Embassy officials (Middle Eastern countries) have facilitated overseas commercial  transplants in Pakistan , Philippines. India mandates embassy relationship affirmation   of foreign donors and recipients . Questioning would pose a problem
Sanjay Nagral  IJME states  des[pite increased  transplants  reducing shortage, there is paucity of ethical  analysis . Indian efforts are the enactment of The Transplantation of Human Organs Act 1994 and its 2011 amendment, the establishment of NOTTO – in line with WHO Guiding principles. . The effects of these legal provisions have been highlighted in “Why NOTTO?” and “Legal Developments in Transplantation in India and the 2011 Amendment of THOA1994”.Travel for transplantation may undermine the country's ability to provide transplant services for its own population – the act specifies that allocations are to be made on priority to Indian nationals and lastly  to foreigner. Organ trafficking/ commercial dealings are illegal. Self sufficiency and equitable sharing of organs are facilitated by NOTTO, ROTTOs and SOTTOs,  Organ donbation is a financially neutral act . However as enunciated by Yosuke Shimazono the underground organ market existst. Falsification of documents , projecting commercial donors as near relatives is practiced. .  Australia, Canada, Israel, Japan, Oman, Saudi Arabia and USA as major organ importing countries. International organ trade demands attention, live donors  brought from  Republic of Moldova to US. Both recipients and donors from different countries move to a third country.   Deaths are reported of patients who went abroad for overseas commercial transplants.
Conclusion: For global benefit from the medical advance of transplantation it is mandatory f to uphold ethical values and prevent organ trade.

The WebApp is sponsored by